I've had success with different methods throughout various stages of my financial journey. Initially, I relied on pen and paper, finding great satisfaction in meticulously recording each expense. It held me accountable and made me more mindful of my spending, especially when I saw my total expenses visually adding up.
However, as time grew precious, I transitioned to digital tracking, first with spreadsheets and later with apps like Mint, which you mentioned. The automated process was a huge timesaver and provided comprehensive insights, making it easier to stay on top of my finances. The visual graphics and notifications kept my goals in check.
Lately, I've been experimenting with YNAB (You Need a Budget), which has a great focus on allocating every dollar to specific categories. This method ensures that every expense is accounted for and helps me understand my true spending priorities.
I think the key to effective budgeting is finding what works best for you. Some people prefer the analog approach, while others like the convenience of digital tools. Ultimately, it's about picking a method that suits your habits and helps you gain financial awareness.